Unplayable Ball in a Bunker 'Stupid'? Rule 19.3 Explained

5 min readGolfregels.app editors
Golf ball plugged deep into the steep face of a pot bunker, with a golfer gazing at it thoughtfully

An unplayable ball buried deep in the sand: few situations on the golf course feel as unfair. This week that frustration got a prominent voice. On August 12, PGA Tour winner Michael Kim publicly called the rule for an unplayable ball in a bunker, Rule 19.3, "stupid". His criticism targets one point: if you want to drop your ball outside the bunker, it costs you two penalty strokes, while almost everywhere else on the course a single penalty stroke gets you out of trouble.

For club golfers this is more than tour gossip. A ball plugging into a bunker face happens every week at amateur level. If you do not know your options under Rule 19.3, you will make the wrong choice and waste strokes. Time to lay out the rule, and the fuss around it, clearly.

What was Michael Kim reacting to?

The trigger was a clip the DP World Tour shared of Pablo Larrazabal at the 2019 Made in Denmark tournament, billed as the worst plugged lie you will ever see. His ball sat almost completely buried in a greenside bunker. Larrazabal played it as it lay and moved it only a few inches with a mighty swing, as Yardbarker recalls.

Michael Kim, never shy of a strong opinion, responded on X, as reported by EssentiallySports via Yahoo Sports: "I find it so stupid that you need two penalty shots for taking an unplayable to get out of a bunker."

Kim backed that up with a comparison: from a penalty area you may drop with one penalty stroke and the trouble is behind you. Not in a bunker. There, in his own words, he has to drop "in the same general area and put myself into a half-fried egg lie". In short: pay a penalty stroke and still be standing in the sand, possibly with another rotten lie.

Video for this article

USGA Golf Rule 19.3: Relief Options for Unplayable Ball in a Bunker

How Rule 19.3 works for an unplayable ball in a bunker

First the foundation: you alone decide whether your ball is unplayable. You may do so anywhere on the course except in a penalty area, and you never have to give a reason. The core rule is Rule 19; if your ball lies in a bunker, Rule 19.3 applies. You have four options:

  1. Stroke and distance, 1 penalty stroke. You play again from the spot of your previous stroke, following the principle of stroke and distance. Important detail: if that spot was outside the bunker, on the fairway for example, you escape the sand for a single penalty stroke.
  2. Back-on-the-line, inside the bunker, 1 penalty stroke. You drop on the line from the hole through the spot where your ball lies, as far back as you like, but inside the bunker.
  3. Lateral relief, inside the bunker, 1 penalty stroke. You drop within two club-lengths of your ball, no nearer the hole, again inside the bunker.
  4. Back-on-the-line, outside the bunker, 2 penalty strokes in total. This is the extra option under Rule 19.3b: the same line straight back, but now you may drop outside the bunker. It is the only drop option that guarantees an escape from the sand, and it is exactly this option that carries the second penalty stroke Kim objects to.

With every option you let the ball fall from knee height into the correct drop zone; the details are covered by the rules for dropping a ball.

Why does escaping cost two penalty strokes?

The logic of the R&A and the USGA is that a bunker is a hazard you are meant to play out of. Rule 12 therefore treats the bunker as a distinct part of the course with its own restrictions. Escaping without playing a bunker shot has to cost something extra, otherwise every nasty lie in the sand could be bought off at the same price as a simple drop.

The rule has also been softened before. Until 2019 you could not drop outside the bunker at all for an unplayable ball, except via stroke and distance. The two-stroke option was added precisely as an escape hatch for situations like Larrazabal's. The two penalty strokes are not spite but a deliberate price tag: the rule guarantees you a way out and asks something in return.

Does Kim have a point?

Partly. His comparison with penalty areas holds up if you look purely at consistency: into the water, one penalty stroke, and you are out. Into a bunker, and the guaranteed way out costs double. A single penalty stroke would also help pace of play, especially at amateur level.

On the other hand, a bunker, unlike a pond, is designed to be played from. You leave a penalty area because playing is often physically impossible; a bunker shot is a normal golf stroke you can practise. Make escaping too cheap and the strategic weight of every pot bunker disappears, along with the reward for players who have mastered their sand game. And the cheap route already exists: stroke and distance for one penalty stroke, even back to a spot outside the sand.

Golfregels app icon
Golfregels App for iPhone and iPad

All rules, practice exams and an AI Coach with photo recognition. Free to download.

App StoreGoogle Play

What do you do with a plugged ball?

Next time you face a ball half swallowed by a bunker face, run through this list:

Michael Kim calls the rule stupid, the rule makers call it logical. What matters more for your score is that you know exactly what every option costs in the moment. That is guaranteed to save strokes, with or without a change to Rule 19.3.

Sources

Rules in this article

Rule 12: Playing from the BunkerRule 14: Marking, Lifting and Dropping Your BallRule 17: Penalty Areas: Your Ball in Tricky TerrainRule 18: Lost Ball, Out of Bounds, or Playing a ProvisionalRule 19: Rescue Option: Your Ball Is UnplayablePractise these rules in the course →

Also read